Lindemann doesn't know Literature!

Okay, my biggest problem with Erika Lindemann is her idea of losing literature in a composition classroom. I understand her take on the composition classroom and that it is strictly to teach composition; but seriously, studnets need content in order to write. Literature offers a great springboard for composition; and if the teacher knows how to incorporate the literature into the curriculum without turning the classroom into a literature course, then why not use all forms of literature in a composition classroom?

Lindemann seems to go against what the other theorists believe. She wants a comp. class to be only a comp. class. Nevermind the social learning that Bruffe discusses, or the arguing Graff urges, the collaboration encouraged by Lunsford, and the cultural, personal, and academic discourses Bizzell wants in a classroom; no, no, no, only composition. That is what I got from Lindemann. Writing is difficult, and good writing is almost impossible according to her. I think she has it backwards. If a teacher uses fiction, nonfiction, poetry, drama, etc. in a composition classroom then teaches the students how to synthesize and analyze (how to think) then writing is meaningful. Outside of an English class students are going to need to know how to synthesize and analyze in any profession. It is the thinking and the skill that is required to write well.

I can teach Hamlet or Skinner's Walden Two to my composition students and teach them how to write in various genres using the literature. Look to the literature as a means for teaching social interaction, historical significance so our students are not culturally illiterate, and analysis of situation. I cannot embrace Ms. Lindemann and her theory about axing literature in a composition classroom. If that is the case, then let us go back to focusing solely on grammar, vocabulary, conventions and forget about how literature can assist in these areas in a composition classroom. I am sorry, but reading and speaking improve writing; and it is the teacher's responsibility to understand how to use literature to teach composition responsibly. Later Lindemann!